Kolkata: Three Arrested for Alleged Gang Rape of College Student in Kasba
The City’s Quiet is Broken
On the surface, Kasba in South Kolkata has the look of quiet routine—residential pockets, small businesses, students on scooters, and the lifeline of EM Bypass nearby. But on that fateful June evening, the silence of this otherwise modest neighborhood was torn apart by an act so brutal that it jolted not just the locality, but the conscience of the city.
A college student, reportedly lured and subsequently gang raped, has triggered fresh questions about women’s safety, systemic policing failures, and the burden survivors must bear in India’s densely populated urban settings.
The Survivor’s Story – A Night of Trust Betrayed
It was a Friday night like many others. The 21-year-old college student, a second-year undergraduate majoring in English literature, had finished classes for the week and was reportedly out with acquaintances—individuals she thought she could trust. According to the preliminary police report, the group met at a casual hangout spot near the Kasba connector.
As per the survivor’s statement to police officials, what started as friendly conversation and light refreshments soon turned sinister. She alleges that the men—three of them—coerced her under the pretext of dropping her home. Instead, she was taken to a vacant flat in the Kasba area. What followed was a horrifying chain of events spanning several hours.
Sources within the Bidhannagar South police division say the woman managed to escape the location and report the incident herself, demonstrating not just courage but an unshakable resolve to fight back.
The Arrest – Fast Response or PR Optics?
Kolkata Police wasted no time in publicizing the arrests. Within 24 hours of the FIR being registered, they had detained three individuals. The arrests were made from various parts of South Kolkata, indicating an organized pursuit. One of the accused was reportedly picked up from his relative’s house in Garia, another from Tollygunge, and the third from a hideout near Kalikapur.
But while the arrests were swift, questions remain:
- Were the accused under surveillance prior to arrest?
- Is there a wider network involved in similar predatory behavior in the area?
- Why was a known abandoned flat not under any form of community policing or neighborhood watch?
Senior police officials, under mounting public pressure, issued a press release stating that all three men had been booked under IPC Sections 376D (gang rape) and 120B (criminal conspiracy). The accused are currently in judicial custody, with an internal probe underway.
The Community Reacts – From Shock to Anger
Residents of Kasba, particularly women-led community groups and local student organizations, organized candlelight vigils within 48 hours of the incident. Many carried placards that read:
- “We Will Not Be Silent”
- “Justice for Every Daughter”
- “Kasba Will Not Forget”
At the heart of the protest was a simple demand: Accountability.
Several female students from nearby colleges like South City and Lady Brabourne took to social media and offline forums, sharing their own stories of harassment in and around Kasba, Gariahat, and Ballygunge. It became clear that this wasn’t just about one survivor, but a larger, systemic threat lurking in the shadows of Kolkata’s suburbs.
Police Response – Swift Action or Symbolic Gesture?
In a press conference held at Lalbazar, Kolkata Police Commissioner Vineet Kumar Goyal stated that the case would be handled with “the highest priority.” He further claimed that a special woman-led task force had been set up to assist the survivor and ensure the investigation remains trauma-informed and swift.
However, activists remain skeptical.
“Fast arrests look good in headlines,” said Ananya Bhattacharya, a lawyer and women’s rights activist based in Park Street. “But how many such cases actually see a conviction? That’s the real question.”
Political Silence and the Gender Debate
As news of the gang rape broke, one thing was notably absent—statements from leading political figures in the state. Neither the Chief Minister nor leaders from the opposition made immediate public comments, a silence that drew sharp criticism online.
Social commentators pointed out that while political parties are quick to mobilize around electoral campaigns and communal issues, gender-based violence often gets relegated to bureaucratic responses and legalese, rather than becoming a matter of political will.
The First Step Toward Justice
In many ways, this is not a new story. It is a grim reminder of the violence women endure across cities, towns, and rural India—often at the hands of men they know, in places they consider safe.
But what makes this case different is the unwavering resolve of the survivor, who despite immense trauma, came forward and stood her ground.
The road ahead will involve:
- A forensic and psychological evaluation
- Recording of statements under Section 164 CrPC
- Formal chargesheet submission
- Possible trial in a fast-track court
Justice is never guaranteed. But the survivor’s voice, now echoed by the city’s collective anger, has ensured one thing—this case will not disappear quietly.
India’s legal framework for addressing sexual assault has evolved considerably over the past decade, especially after the 2012 Nirbhaya case sparked mass protests and landmark legislative reforms. Yet, between the codified statutes and the lived experience of survivors lies a chasm of procedural inertia, institutional bias, and societal silence. Nowhere is this disconnect more visible than in metropolitan cities like Kolkata—where despite an educated population and robust media presence, justice remains uncertain for victims of sexual violence.
This part explores what happens after the arrest—the journey through the legal-medical-investigative system that determines whether justice will merely be promised or actually delivered.
The Medical Maze – Examining a Survivor’s Body and Dignity
Immediately after the FIR was filed, the survivor in the Kasba case was taken to MR Bangur Hospital, one of the few authorized centers for medico-legal examinations in South Kolkata.
The Procedure:
- A two-member female medical team conducted the examination, as per protocol.
- The survivor was subjected to tests for genital injuries, DNA swabs, and semen traces.
- Blood and urine samples were collected to test for possible sedative or narcotic substances.
While the law mandates consent-driven, trauma-informed medical exams, the actual experience often lacks sensitivity.
“They asked me to describe it all again, and again, in front of people I didn’t even know,” the survivor reportedly told a counselor later.
“It felt like I was being examined more for my character than my body.”
Although the West Bengal Health Department introduced SOPs for sexual assault examinations in 2022, several government hospitals still lack dedicated forensic examiners, privacy-focused rooms, and trained counselors.
The Legal Process – Laws that Protect, Systems that Delay
West Bengal’s handling of rape cases, legally speaking, is bound by the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013.
In the Kasba case, the accused have been booked under:
- Section 376D (gang rape)
- Section 120B (criminal conspiracy)
- Sections related to wrongful confinement and intimidation
After the medical report and survivor’s Section 164 CrPC statement (recorded before a magistrate) are completed, the police must file a chargesheet within 90 days.
However, in practice:
- Chargesheets are often delayed due to pending forensic lab reports.
- Witness protection is almost non-existent, especially in cases where the accused are from the same locality.
- Survivors frequently drop out of cases under pressure, stigma, or fear of social alienation.
Data from the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) reveals that of the 1,315 rape cases registered in West Bengal in 2023, only about 23% reached conviction by early 2024.
Police Conduct – Progressive Reform or Performative Policing?
Kolkata Police has made visible strides in sensitizing officers toward gender-based crimes. The city has:
- Special women’s help desks in all major police stations
- Dedicated female officers trained in survivor-first approaches
- A helpline number (1091) promoted in schools and colleges
But many of these systems exist more on paper than in practice.
In the Kasba case:
- Police were quick to act after media attention escalated.
- However, the initial report was allegedly only registered under Section 354 (molestation), and upgraded to 376D after intervention from the survivor’s lawyer.
- The survivor’s legal team reportedly had to insist on collection of CCTV footage and digital forensic backup from the accused’s phones.
A retired DCP from South Kolkata admitted, under condition of anonymity:
“There’s still a deep-rooted culture where officers try to ‘discourage’ rape cases unless there’s public pressure or visible injury. It’s a combination of backlog, gender bias, and fear of low conviction rates.”
The Judiciary – Promise of Fast-Track Courts, Reality of Bottlenecks
West Bengal has designated fast-track courts in each district for crimes against women. But these courts are overburdened, and sometimes judges are transferred or vacancies remain unfilled for months.
In Kolkata:
- Fast-track courts currently handle over 3,800 pending sexual assault cases.
- Lawyers specializing in such cases complain of adjournments, non-appearance of witnesses, and slow forensic labs.
- Survivors often wait 3–4 years for a final verdict, during which time their personal lives are scrutinized, their academic or work life disrupted, and their mental health deteriorates.
In the Kasba case, public demand for a time-bound trial has increased. Legal experts suggest that unless civil society continues to amplify the case, bureaucratic drift may set in.
Psychological Fallout – The Invisible Battle
Every rape survivor walks away from the crime with more than just physical injuries. The psychological trauma, often silent and unseen, lasts far longer.
Thankfully, the survivor in this case has been referred to a state-recognized trauma counselor, working with the West Bengal Commission for Women. But such interventions are the exception, not the norm.
In most cases:
- Mental health care is not included in the criminal justice process.
- Survivors drop out of college, relocate, or even attempt suicide.
- Media houses, even when well-intentioned, violate privacy or sensationalize the event.
The National Mental Health Survey (2019) found that 62% of rape survivors experience long-term PTSD, and yet only 7% receive formal counseling support.
A System Both Evolving and Failing
Kolkata’s handling of the Kasba gang rape case is emblematic of India’s complex relationship with gender-based violence. While laws have strengthened, and police action appears more prompt, the lived experience of survivors continues to be shaped by apathy, prejudice, and delay.
The question is no longer whether our systems are failing. The question is whether they’re evolving fast enough to protect the next victim.
NCRB 2023 Data on Urban Sexual Violence:
- Delhi: 1,745 rape cases
- Mumbai: 944 rape cases
- Bengaluru: 712 rape cases
- Kolkata: 503 rape cases
These numbers reflect reported cases. Countless more go unreported due to stigma, fear, or institutional apathy.
Urban areas often mask danger with development. Well-lit roads and metro networks are offset by dark alleys, unmonitored taxis, and predator-friendly anonymity. Women may have the freedom to work late, travel independently, or go out socially—but they don’t have safety guaranteed at any step.
Recurring Case Studies – Echoes of Kasba
To understand the Kasba incident, one must look at similar cases across Indian cities:
🔹 The 2012 Delhi Gang Rape (Nirbhaya):
A physiotherapy intern was gang raped in a moving bus and left to die. It sparked nationwide protests and led to the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013. But 11 years on, Delhi is still called “rape capital.”
🔹 Mumbai’s Shakti Mills Case (2013):
A photojournalist was gang raped inside a defunct textile mill compound. All five accused were convicted, two awarded the death penalty. Despite the convictions, Mumbai’s public spaces remain unsafe after dark.
🔹 Bengaluru’s PG Horror (2020):
Multiple women accused a PG owner and staff of drugging and sexually exploiting them. Though initially dismissed as a “property dispute,” deeper investigation revealed a sex racket with political links.
🔹 Salt Lake Park Rape, Kolkata (2019):
A woman was assaulted while jogging early morning. The accused was a repeat offender and the park had zero CCTV surveillance, highlighting the city’s lax civic planning for women’s safety.
These cases reveal that patterns repeat—trusted environments, poor lighting or surveillance, delayed police response, victim-blaming narratives, and a lack of community accountability.
Where Urban Governance Fails Women
Municipal corporations, police departments, and urban planners often ignore the gender lens when designing infrastructure.
Urban Flaws That Enable Violence:
- Poorly lit streets and parks
- Sparse public toilets for women
- Unregulated cabs and shared transport
- Inadequate street-level policing
- Lack of women-only shelters and legal aid centers
In Kasba, the assault happened in a vacant flat in a semi-residential area. Residents later told media that the building had been deserted for months—a known drug-use and crime spot. Why wasn’t it sealed or monitored? The answer lies in bureaucratic apathy and fragmented urban jurisdiction.
Kolkata, like many Indian cities, has overlapping civic bodies—KMDA, KMC, Bidhannagar Police, etc.—each deflecting responsibility when tragedies strike.
Cultural Silence – Blaming the Victim, Not the System
The cultural response to rape remains disturbingly archaic, even in India’s most cosmopolitan neighborhoods.
- “Why was she out late?”
- “What was she wearing?”
- “Was she drinking?”
- “Did she know the boys?”
These are not questions for the accused. These are questions asked of survivors—by police, family, media, and sometimes, even the judiciary. Such moral scrutiny deterrents survivors from speaking out.
In the Kasba case, the student was reportedly known to the accused. Local gossip quickly painted her as “too modern,” “too free,” or “too social.” As if her autonomy justified her assault.
Until Indian cities stop tolerating misogynistic narratives, no law or surveillance camera can protect women from harm.
The Digital Age of Violence
Technology has brought new threats:
- Deepfake pornography
- Stalkerware apps
- Morpshed photos on Telegram groups
- Revenge porn on social media
Perpetrators now use smartphones and the internet not just to record, but to disseminate sexual violence. And cities are hubs for these crimes.
The Kolkata Police Cyber Cell receives over 50 complaints a week related to image-based sexual abuse, yet conviction rates remain under 5%. Women often withdraw complaints due to social stigma, marriage pressure, or fear of backlash.
In Kasba, one of the accused reportedly filmed part of the assault. The police are now working with cyber experts to recover deleted footage from his phone—a task that may decide the trial’s outcome.
The Urban Mirage
India’s cities promise safety, opportunity, and equality. But beneath the surface, a culture of silence, indifference, and misogyny festers—allowing violence to occur again and again.
If the gang rape in Kasba is to mean anything beyond headlines, it must serve as a reckoning for the urban imagination itself. A city is only as progressive as its protection of the most vulnerable.
The media plays a dual-edged role in cases like Kasba. On one hand, immediate reportage:
- Brings national attention to a local crime
- Forces police into faster response
- Puts pressure on politicians and institutions to act
But once the initial burst fades, media houses often:
- Move on to the next crime, next TRP cycle
- Reduce complex legal updates to single-line briefs
- Fail to follow up on trial status or systemic gaps
Examples:
- The 2020 Hathras gang rape case drew massive media and public scrutiny. But when the trial began in 2021, courtroom proceedings were barely covered.
- The Shakti Mills case saw extensive press attention during sentencing. But the survivor’s later life, reintegration struggles, and legal appeals were largely ignored.
In the Kasba case, after a week of front-page coverage and interviews with officials, newsrooms have already shifted focus—from safety to politics, from justice to elections.
Survivors Left Alone – The Emotional Toll of Waiting
After arrests are made and charges filed, survivors often enter the longest and most emotionally grueling phase: waiting.
They wait for:
- Forensic reports from underfunded labs
- Court hearings that are postponed without explanation
- Witness protection that never materializes
- Counseling support that fades after the headlines vanish
In the Kasba case, the survivor—currently living away from her family home—has already missed two semesters of college. Her academic re-entry is uncertain. Her personal life, under scrutiny. Her social media, deactivated after online harassment.
“She has to relive it again and again—for lawyers, for doctors, for police. And when the media moves on, it feels like she’s the only one still trapped in that night,” said a counselor from an NGO now supporting the survivor.
The Courtroom Labyrinth – How Cases Collapse
Even in metropolitan courts, trials for sexual violence suffer from:
- Adjournments due to backlog or absentee judges
- Witnesses turning hostile under pressure
- Poor coordination between investigating officers and public prosecutors
- Delay in forensic submissions or authenticity questions
In many cases, defense lawyers attack the survivor’s character, bringing in phone records, social media posts, or even private photos to argue “consent” or “provocation.”
The Indian Evidence Act was amended to prevent questions about a rape survivor’s sexual history—but in practice, these violations persist subtly, especially in lower courts.
In the Kasba case, legal experts worry that unless the CCTV footage, digital evidence, and survivor’s statement are airtight, the defense may attempt to spin a “consensual encounter gone wrong” narrative.
Police Accountability – Momentum Fizzles Fast
While Kolkata Police acted swiftly in arresting the accused in the Kasba incident, the real test lies in follow-through:
- Are senior officers ensuring coordination between departments?
- Has an internal audit been done on how the abandoned flat was being misused?
- Has the area seen increased patrolling or community policing since the incident?
Unfortunately, past cases suggest that police urgency often fizzles out after public pressure subsides.
Without constant oversight, FIRs are amended quietly, evidence goes unexamined, and loopholes creep into the chargesheet. Many crimes that begin as “gang rape” cases are eventually diluted to “sexual assault” or “outraging modesty.”
The Role of Civil Society – A Light in the Silence
When media and institutions fail, it is often NGOs, feminist collectives, and local activists who keep the flame of justice alive.
In Kolkata, groups like:
- Swayam
- Prajaak
- Aparajita Foundation
have been instrumental in:
- Providing trauma counseling
- Guiding legal process
- Helping survivors reintegrate socially and academically
- Documenting long-term trial progress
They ensure that cases like Kasba don’t fade into statistics, but remain a rallying point for systemic reform.
Yet, these groups are often underfunded, overworked, and politically targeted—highlighting the fragile ecosystem survivors must navigate to claim their rights.
Headlines Are Not Justice
Justice is not a viral tweet. It’s not a screaming anchor or a trending hashtag. It’s a long, silent, often solitary battle that survivors wage in courtrooms, classrooms, homes, and their own minds.
The Kasba gang rape case may have shocked Kolkata into conversation—but will the city stay with the survivor until the final verdict?
That answer will determine whether India’s urban heart can evolve into a truly just and safe space for women, or whether these stories will remain sensational news cycles, without systemic change.
Also Read : Bihar Electoral Roll Revision Begins as EC Launches NRC-Like Voter Verification Drive
